The Death of Marcus Aurelius

The Death of Marcus Aurelius

Thursday, May 10, 2018

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 4.42



Constantly regard the Universe as one living being, having one substance and one soul.

And observe how all things have reference to one perception, the perception of this one living being.

And how all things act with one movement.

And how all things are the cooperating causes of all things that exist.

Observe too the continuous spinning of the thread and the contexture of the web.

—Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, Book 4 (tr Long)

This is a passage charged with metaphysical meaning, and it is the sort of thinking that can reveal deep disagreements from different perspectives and schools. A traditional theist may object that this is pantheism, because it fails to distinguish between God and creation. A modern secularist may object that the very idea of an ordered Universe, under one Divine Mind, is unscientific. So the different sides take their corners, and they fight it out.

The division about such matter stands in a sharp contrast to the very unity of all things to which Marcus Aurelius is appealing. 

Questions about the ultimate order, purpose, and cause of the entire Universe may be difficult to approach, but they are hardly beyond the sound consideration of reason, and they are the necessary foundation for how our own lives find a place together with all other things.

I once found a very small, oddly shaped piece of metal under my bed. I had no idea what it did, and I could have easily just tossed it away, but I put it aside. It was only many months later that I realized what it was, a part of the end clasp for a watch chain I had inherited from my great-grandfather. The clasp and the chain were reunited, and not only was a whole object brought back together, but my heart was brought back together.

One piece of metal played a part in a chain, the chain was there to carry a watch, the watch was there to tell time, the measure of time helps me to live my life well, and living my life well can hopefully serve anything and everything. One piece of metal also played a part in something else, how much people can mean to one another, and how a tiny part of something can remind us of all the bigger things in life that matter the most.

I could try to write a whole book about the one and the many, about unity and diversity, about the whole and the parts, about God and creation, about transcendence and immanence. I could try to reference the Bible and the Upanishads, Parmenides and Heraclitus, St. Augustine and St. Thomas, Spinoza and Leibniz. How are things the same, and how are they different? Do they share in the very same identity, or do they participate with one another? I could speak of atheism, theism, pantheism, and panentheism.

That task is far beyond my own ability, and while I often ponder the theory, I leave its expression to the more gifted. What remains most important to me, in humble daily practice, is how I should consider the one and the many in the way I choose to live.

What I do certainly know is that while I am different from the pen and paper in front of me, or the neighbor laughing loudly next door, or the cat just now asking to be let into the yard, all of these things are also one and the same. They are different because they express different qualities, but the substance, existence itself, as understood in the original Stoic sense, is identical.

The existence of any one thing, however I choose to philosophically understand existence, is inseparable from the existence of any other thing. They have no being apart, but only being together. There is no me without everything around me, and there is no everything without all the bits that compose it. That even includes me.

However we may choose to understand it, we are all one. There is one joined perception that makes us the same, one joined movement that makes us the same, and one joined cooperation that makes us the same. We may kick and fight and protest all we like; in doing so, we only end up playing the part we wish to reject.

With all respect, to the traditional theist: By all means, look to the benefit of what you say is somehow up there. Now consider how what is up there, by the order of causes, is also present within everything down here.

With all respect, to the modern secularist: By all means, look to the benefit of what you say is somehow down here. Now consider how what is down here, by the order of causes, is also present within everything up there.

With all respect, to each and every one of us: By all means, define yourself as yourself. Now consider that the only reason the “you” and the “I” are ever in conflict is because we have forgotten how we are one.

Written in 1/2006

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 4.41



What is evil to you does not subsist in the ruling principle of another, nor yet in any turning and mutation of your corporeal covering.

Where is it then? It is in that part of you in which subsists the power of forming opinions about evils. Let this power then not form such opinions, and all is well.

And if that which is nearest to it, the poor body, is burnt, filled with matter and rottenness, nevertheless let the part which forms opinions about these things be quiet, that is, let it judge that nothing is either bad or good which can happen equally to the bad man and the good.

For that which happens equally to him who lives contrary to Nature and to him who lives according to Nature, is neither according to Nature nor contrary to Nature.

—Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, Book 4 (tr Long)

Having come into this world at the height of Flower Power, I was quite familiar with the many appeals to having a “positive attitude”. I found, however, that this was often not considered with much depth, and I was never satisfied being told that it required “just having good thoughts.” What made the thoughts good, and how should I go about forming them? I know, nobody likes the annoying fellow who asks the awkward questions.

I also noticed that for many, the purpose of a good attitude was seen as a means of receiving good things, and not about a means for doing them. I immediately wondered if I should expect the quality of my thinking or wishing to somehow directly change what happened in the world, or whether it more properly served to change me?

I remember some of the business gurus of the 1980’s arguing that if I only thought rich hard enough, I would then become rich. I naturally asked if making money would make me truly rich at all, and if there were better things at which to direct my willpower.

Yet there is something deeply Stoic about the idea that my happiness depends on my thinking, if only I understand the context rightly. I need to clarify for myself what form my thoughts should be taking, and what I might expect in return for modifying my thinking.

Once my estimation shifts from seeking the good in the thinking of others, or in the circumstances of my body and my surroundings, to seeking the good in my own judgment itself, I have made the most necessary change in my attitude. From this, I can proceed to recognizing how anything that happens to me will only be as good or bad for me as I decide to make it. What is usually understood as gain or loss, triumph or tragedy, is all equally an opportunity for making myself better.

For all the effort I can put into planning and execution, the world will unfold on its own terms. I am left with only one thing that is distinctly mine, and that I can rely upon without question. This is the merit of my own actions, how anything I can do reflects my love for my own nature, within the harmony of all of Nature.

I need not think of my circumstances defining me, or wishing them to be one way or another. Things around me may seem to fall apart, I may be surrounded by malice, and my situation may seem hopeless. It is hardly so, because the hope isn’t from the situation, but in what I can make of myself in the situation.

I deeply appreciate how Marcus Aurelius observes that both good and bad men will confront exactly the same things in life, and will only differ in how they make sense and use of them. Good and bad folks can both be rich or poor, healthy or sick, loved or unloved, have the world handed to them a silver platter or struggle to hang on by their fingernails.

If Providence had wanted such things to be our measure, she would have made the good guys worldly successes, and the bad guys worldly failures. She could perhaps have ironically done the exact reverse. She did neither, but it is all mixed and blended together, each of us with our distinct baggage.

A positive attitude isn’t about changing, by power or cleverness, the cards I have been dealt, but playing that hand with integrity and justice. I believe this should be the form of my own thinking, and also itself the reward I can hope to expect. Whatever is fully good asks for nothing beyond itself.

Written in 12/2005

Image: Cassius Marcellus Coolidge, Poker Game (1894)


Wednesday, May 9, 2018

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 4.40



Examine men's ruling principles, even those of the wise, what kind of things they avoid, and what kind they pursue.

—Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, Book 4 (tr Long)

I started learning long ago how helpful it could be to simply observe the way people behaved. This perhaps came easier for me, because I was usually the awkward and quiet fellow, and I was very rarely noticed by others. I may have often felt neglected, but this gave me a priceless opportunity to figure out what made people tick.

I could look around to see what people said and did, but I could also begin to see patterns of why they may have said and done those things. It was never about reaching into their minds to reveal their motives, but about considering how their words and deeds on the outside indirectly reflected what they wanted on the inside. This, in turn, could give me a sense of what was important to them, what they both desired and feared.

I can learn just as easily from both the foolish and the wise, from the vicious and the virtuous, and from all the degrees in between. It is as helpful to see all the warnings of how not to live, as well as the inspirations for how to live.

Their ruling principles become apparent in their actions. If they work to increase their possessions, or their reputations, or the satisfaction of their passions, and employ all other things in the service of those ends, this tells me much about them. They are quite different from those who work to improve themselves, regardless of whether there is some external payment, or if anyone else is looking, or if an immediate pleasure has to be surrendered for what is right.

I will sometimes make three sorts of mistakes when examining others, and each of these errors will hinder me from learning about how I, in turn, should live.

First, I should not confuse how people wish to appear in their words and actions, from what they actually want from their words and actions. This may be difficult to unravel, but true character, and not merely the illusion of character, will usually reveal itself quickly where the rubber meets the road, when there is a true test of priorities.

Second, I should not confuse understanding others with condemning or dismissing others. Once I observe a harmful or ignorant principle in any action, I immediately make it useless for my own improvement if I am harmful or ignorant within myself.

Third, no amount of observation will be of any use to me if I do not apply what I have learned, whether it is about what is good or bad, to my own decisions and actions. I cringe to think of how many times I knew full well that people were acting out of selfishness or in bad faith, but I trusted and followed them anyway, because my own principles were still disordered.

The best education in living will always be watching how people live, and learning from this what meaning and purpose is best for living.

Written in 12/2005

Tuesday, May 8, 2018

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 4.39



You will soon die, and you are not yet simple, not free from perturbations, or without suspicion of being hurt by external things, or kindly disposed towards all; nor do you yet place wisdom only in acting justly.

—Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, Book 4 (tr Long)

It hurts to hear it, but it is completely true. Marcus Aurelius is, of course, speaking to himself, but he might as well be sitting down with me over a very strong cup of coffee.

The Stoics will often speak of “the sage”, the man who has finally come to rise above all the shallow and petty things in this life, and who now chooses, with joy, tranquility, and complete self-giving, to dedicate his entire existence to wisdom and virtue. Nothing else may touch him, or if a longing for externals reaches out to touch him, he can gently put them aside. Circumstance and fate no longer harm him, because he does not allow them to rule over him.

He may have something in common, I suppose, with the bodhisattva of Buddhism, or the rishi of Hinduism. In the Catholic faith I was raised in, we informally called such people living saints, as much as that troubled the more precise theologians.

I leave aside, for the moment, the question of whether there are such truly perfected people in this life, or whether it is a noble ideal for our aspirations. I do know, however, that I have been blessed by knowing people, only a few, who come at least mightily close to achieving that complete goal. I keep them in my heart and mind every day as an inspiration.

Now I might complain about how many obstacles stand in my way, or I may choose to do my best to overcome those obstacles. Most of us are dedicated to wealth, fame, and a long life. The Stoic is dedicated to understanding, character, and a good life. Each of us can channel all that energy committed to externals, and redirect it to internals. The choice is right here, right now. Then, we would have far fewer important people, but far more decent people.

Simplicity? Less is more, not because less is itself better, but because life needs no more than what Nature provides.

Free from perturbations? Worry only about what is within my power, and never about what is beyond it. Nature manages the rest.

Without being hurt by external things? As a being of reason, choice, and action, I will only harm myself by abusing my reason, choice, and action.

Kindly disposed towards all? There is never a reason to hate anyone or anything. There is only a reason to correct my own hatred for anyone or anything.

Acting justly? I may be treated unjustly, but that is neither here nor there. The grasping of others need not make me grasping within myself.

Written in 12/2005

 

Monday, May 7, 2018

Boethius, The Consolation 1.17



. . . “Since you were always present to guide me in my words and my deeds, I think you remember what happened at Verona. When King Theodoric, desiring the common ruin of the Senate, was for extending to the whole order the charge of treason laid against Albinus, you remember how I labored to defend the innocence of the order without any care for my own danger? You know that I declare this truthfully and with no boasting praise of self. For the secret value of a conscience, that approves its own action, is lessened somewhat each time that it receives the reward of fame by displaying its deeds.

“But you see what end has fallen upon my innocence. In the place of the rewards of honest virtue, I am suffering the punishments of an ill deed that was not mine. And did ever any direct confession of a crime find its judges so well agreed upon exercising harshness, that neither the liability of the human heart to err, nor the changeableness of the fortune of all mankind, could yield one dissenting voice?

“If it had been said that I had wished to burn down temples, to murder with sacrilegious sword their priests, that I had planned the massacre of all good citizens, even so I should have been present to plead guilty or to be convicted, before the sentence was executed. But here am I, nearly five hundred miles away, without the opportunity of defending myself, condemned to death and the confiscation of my property because of my too great zeal for the Senate.

“Ah! Well have they deserved that none should ever be liable to be convicted on such a charge! Even those who laid information have seen the honor of this accusation, for, that they might blacken it with some criminal ingredient, they had need to lie, saying that I had violated my conscience by using unholy means to obtain offices corruptly.” . . .

—from Book 1, Prose 4

“No good deed goes unpunished,” they would plaintively tell me, and I would wonder if this was intended to encourage me or discourage me in being good. Where is there any good in the deed, if it will not, in turn, yield good things? Am I misunderstanding the whole nature of true rewards and true punishments?

The irony of his situation is not lost on Boethius, as it not lost on anyone who has been in the same sort of place. Boethius intended to do right by the Senate, and to save its members from harm. Instead, the very people he was trying to protect have turned on him, and seeing the way the wind was blowing, are now more than happy to accuse him of a crime, however much they have to lie to make their own case, or deny him the right to defend himself.

I recall how my third grade teacher was convinced that a girl in the class has stolen some art supplies from the classroom during the lunch break, and the girl’s friend insisted that couldn’t be true, because they had been together the whole time. Now both girls had their parents called, one for being a thief, the other for being a liar.

A decent and honest fellow I knew very well later told me he had seen the art supplies in another child’s bag, but he said he was too afraid to say anything. Unpleasant experiences like that have a way of sticking with you. I can still vividly picture those two girls sitting outside the principal’s office, both crying.

We may need to face unpleasant consequences for following what we think is right, but is that a reason to stand down? Should we only speak out or act up when the results are going to be convenient?

Boethius is angered by the results, yet he still has a sense in this passage that right and wrong are not merely measured by their utility. He knows, for example, that following his conscience, and the private knowledge of his own virtue, are themselves their own reward, regardless of whether he is praised. After all, he says, he did the right thing for its own sake, not to show off, or because of any recognition.

Is it that much of a stretch to also say that following his conscience, and the private knowledge of his own virtue, are themselves their own reward, regardless of whether he is condemned?

If virtue is something good, it will surely bring us benefit. The question, however, is what sort of benefit that will be, and what measure of reward the good man should seek. Are fame, riches, and even the life of the body things worth caring about for their own sake, or are there perhaps some greater standards to live up to?

Help me to understand the whole nature of true rewards and true punishments in this life, so that I can learn to be happy with my own actions. 

Written in 6/2015

 

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 4.38



Observe constantly that all things take place by change, and accustom yourself to consider that the nature of the Universe loves nothing so much as to change the things which are, and to make new things like them.

For everything that exists is in a manner the seed of that which will be.

But you are thinking only of seeds that are cast into the earth, or into a womb; but this is a very vulgar notion.

—Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, Book 4 (tr Long)

I have quite a few weaknesses of disposition and character, and one of my greatest is surely my sense of nostalgia. I like things the way I remember them, at some ideal moment in my mind. Change will therefore often frustrate me.

I accordingly need to remind myself every day that it is never best for anything to be preserved in some static state. Transformation is never the destruction of something, but the beginning of something else, and the order of change is precisely how being expresses itself most fully.

Everything is a seed for something else, and not just in the narrow sense of how living things reproduce. Each circumstance, relation, or state of affairs is, in turn, the grounds out of which all things are renewed. It helps me to think of the stages of change itself as harmonious and beautiful, where existence is actualized and perfected in becoming.

Whether I may find anything pleasant or painful, I need to look at it from the side of its own purpose. It was something different, it is even now being altered, and it will soon be something else. It is right and good that the Universe is constantly active, and not merely passive. After all, it would hardly be much of a Universe if it didn’t do anything.

A distinctly human flaw can be wishing for something to be different than it is now, and either looking to the past for relief, which is always my temptation, or hoping for something else in the future. I can’t be thinking of these different aspects as being separate from one another, or being able to exist independently, for each is a part of the whole.

Many years ago, I would resent being young, and I wanted to be older, and now I will equally resent being old, and I want to be young again. Like any good story, the beginning, the middle, and the end, all work together, and it hardly makes sense to read only one chapter over and over, or to read them out of order. Even as the players change, no story ever really ends at all, and it becomes the start of a whole new story.

I can certainly appreciate the past, though I serve myself very poorly when I think only of the past. The past can still be good for me, but only in the sense that it made possible what I can be now, and what will ultimately become of me. It is a package deal.

I used to think it quite sentimental when people advised me to always tell the people I love how much they matter, because what was said before had become distant, and what can be said in the future is never guaranteed. I appreciate this far more lately. As with all things in Stoicism, there is no time like the now, even as it will never be the same the next time I look at it.

Written in 11/2005


Saturday, May 5, 2018

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 4.37



Everything is only for a day, both that which remembers and that which is remembered.

—Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, Book 4 (tr Long)

I can still precisely remember her every word, every aspect of the room, how the sun shone into the space, and just how the branches outside swayed in the breeze.

“You’ll always be my best friend. I love you. Nothing will change that. I want to spend the rest of my life with you. Just you.”

Two weeks later, after my aborted marriage proposal, all bets were off. The only time I ever sat down with her again, after my failure, she said that taking my own life was the best option for me.

What was said on one day was most certainly not remembered on the next.

My experience is hardly unique. Too many of us believe in all the shallow promises and commitments, about forever and ever, that we are given by those who are disloyal and dishonest. The world is full of the dismayed, the dismissed, and the heartbroken. They are cast aside and forgotten, while those who treated them poorly smile for the camera.

Thinking of this hurts, but the hurt serves a purpose. Mourning about a loss need never be about hopelessness, but the loss can itself become a means for hope. It’s all about what I choose to care about, and why I might choose to care.

Love matters, but it isn’t about being loved. I was my own victim, by depending on a false promise of eternal devotion. It was certainly within my power to offer love, without condition, but it was not within my power to expect love, without condition.

In the end, none of these passing things make any difference at all. I hoped for something timeless, but nothing is timeless. My own promise is only as good as much as I renew it, through my actions, for each and every second I am alive. It isn’t my place to speak for anyone else’s promises or actions.

Everything is only for a day. This doesn’t mean that we cannot be committed, but that a commitment must be forged at every moment, in every changing circumstance, until we meet our end. Promises are easy to make, but hard to keep. A promise only makes sense when we act it out, right here and now, and then over and over and over again. Tomorrow is easy, but today is hard.

What has happened, what is remembered, becomes meaningless in the face of what I am actually doing. Reputation means nothing. Action means everything.

My rambling thoughts help me to realize how insignificant it is to worry about how anything will be remembered. It matters only how my life was lived, when it was lived.  

Written in 11/2005

Image: A gathering of apparently important students before our graduation in 1992. Even if you have never met me, you'll see which fellow I am. Insightful folks will also recognize the lost love of my life in the picture.  


Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 4.36



Willingly give thyself up to Clotho, one of the Fates, allowing her to spin your thread into whatever things she pleases.

—Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, Book 4 (tr Long)

Marcus Aurelius has already employed the symbol of the thread of life, and here he makes a more specific reference to the Fates, the goddesses of destiny. Clotho spins the thread, Lachesis measures it, and Atropos cuts it.

There does not need to be any terror or despair in considering the concept of fate, because the Stoic understands that what makes life worth living isn’t really determined by externals at all. I might worry that willfully giving myself to destiny is a complete surrender of everything I am, but it is rather an acceptance of the conditions out of which I will determine who I am. It isn’t giving up my will, but being grateful for the tools my will can employ.

Clotho crafts the very fiber out of which I am made, and in doing so she represents all the circumstances of life that I am given. Such things are outside of my power, and while they may seem to be so much of what defines me, what will matter is what is fully within my power, my own choices and actions.

I had a rather Stoic moment about freedom and fate long before I even knew what Stoicism was. In my elementary school library, I was leafing through a book about gangsters, and as I turned the page, there was a striking image of the victims of the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre. A real scene of death was far more frightening than anything I’d seen in the movies.

I noticed how they were all wearing nice suits, and one fellow had a sand-colored fedora perched on his chest. For some reason, I suddenly wondered what these men were thinking when they got dressed that morning, and whether it could possibly have occurred to them that this was the last time they would ever do so.

My reflection arose not from heartlessness, but from a certain sympathy. They may have been hardened criminals, but they were still people like everyone else, and something like this could happen to anyone. If life was that precarious, and even the immediate future so unknown to us, what could ever be reliable?

As my own life unfolded, many things seemed routine, but there were also these sudden explosions of completely unexpected events. I would look back at them in shock, and tell myself, “If I had only known!” I would sometimes remember that photograph.

But it wasn’t my place to know, just as it wasn’t my place to decide what would happen to me. That had already been set by other causes. The only comfort I could ever find was remembering that it was still up to me how I chose to think and live, at any given moment, regardless of any of the circumstances.

Let the thread be spun, measured, and cut however it may, but I can still be myself.

Written in 11/2005

Image: The St. Valentine's Day Massacre, February 14, 1929


 

Friday, May 4, 2018

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 4.35



The words which were formerly familiar are now antiquated.

So also the names of those who were famed of old, are now in a manner antiquated, Camillus, Caeso, Volesus, Leonnatus, and a little after also Scipio and Cato, then Augustus, then also Hadrian and Antoninus.

For all things soon pass away and become a mere tale, and complete oblivion soon buries them. And I say this of those who have shone in a wondrous way. For the rest, as soon as they have breathed out their breath, they are gone, and no man speaks of them.

And, to conclude the matter, what is even an eternal remembrance? A mere nothing.

What then is that about which we ought to employ our serious pains? This one thing, just thoughts, and social acts, and words which never lie, and a disposition which gladly accepts all that happens, as necessary, as usual, as flowing from a principle and source of the same kind.

—Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, Book 4 (tr Long)

I am still a man in middle age, and I already feel like people use different words, or the same words with rather different meanings, than they did only a few decades ago. This is not necessarily a bad thing, but simply a sign of how our human circumstances are always in a state of flux. I can choose to understand these differences, and I can then dedicate myself not just to the meanings of words, but also to the meaning of the Nature behind all of those words.

Most of my students struggle to make sense of Wordsworth or Shakespeare, and one frustrated young fellow told me he felt like the characters in a Twain or Dickens novel were speaking in a different language. I often confuse them even more when I offer anything by Chaucer, and the Old English of Beowulf seems no different to them than Greek. I can hardly blame them.

The names and reputations of those once considered the great men and women of history are no different. I was still given a certain Classical framework in my youth, though that was already quite rare, so every one of the names Marcus Aurelius lists means something to me. Now, I wouldn’t be surprised if only one of those names, Augustus, was even vaguely recognized.

Cato, who? I would ask if we mean the Elder or the Younger, but it is now the name of a women’s fashion retailer.

As I have grown closer to Stoicism, I have increasingly thought that there is no point in teaching the words and names, the places and events, of the past as things to be memorized just for their own sake. We lose our awareness of them once we have filled out the worksheet or taken the test.

Instead, I ask what the thoughts, words, and deeds of any time or place can tell us about human nature as a whole, about the order of Nature of which we are a part, and of the Logos that gives Nature that order. Those are, I believe, the principles that truly matter. Words and names are only as good as the reality they help us to comprehend.

On a moral and personal level, this also helps me remember that status and fame will always come and go, and are useless indicators of any lasting value. I don’t even need to have a Classical education to see that. I can look over the Billboard Charts since they were started in 1936 to see the vanity of recognition.

Most of us are hardly given a second glance even right now, though some of us may be esteemed for a time while we live, about outside qualities that have little to do with who we are on the inside. Only a very few of us will ever be thought of again once we’ve been put back into the ground, and those legends die perhaps a bit more slowly, even as the stories about us are far removed from who we actually were.

Again, this is not necessarily a bad thing. It can be a moment of enlightenment and relief. My name doesn’t matter one bit, even if, by some strange fluke of history, I happened to become one of those folks respected later on for something I may or may not have done. The enlightenment and relief come from allowing me to live well for its own sake, and for absolutely nothing else.

I should think good thoughts, act with love, and respect everything in the world for what it is, by means of the only thing within my power, my own character, and within the only moment I have within my power, the right here and now.

Written in 11/2005

Image: Pieter Bruegel the Elder, The Tower of Babel (c. 1563)


Thursday, May 3, 2018

Boethius, The Consolation 1.16



. . . “But what avails it? No liberty is left to hope for. Would that there were any! I would answer in the words of Canius, who was accused by Gaius Caesar, Germanicus' son, of being cognizant of a plot against himself: ‘If I had known of it, you would not have.’

“And in this matter grief has not so blunted my powers that I should complain of wicked men making impious attacks upon virtue. But at this I do wonder, that they should hope to succeed. Evil desires are, it may be, due to our natural failings, but that the conceptions of any wicked mind should prevail against innocence while God watches over us, seems to me unnatural.

“Wherefore not without cause has one of your own followers asked: ‘If God is, whence come evil things? If He is not, whence come good?’

“Again, let impious men, who thirst for the blood of the whole Senate and of all good citizens, be allowed to wish for the ruin of us too whom they recognize as champions of the Senate and all good citizens. But surely such as I have not deserved the same hatred from the members of the Senate too?” . . .

—from Book 1, Prose 4

Boethius is worried that there is really no prospect for making any of these things better. He thinks of the times of Gaius Caesar, son of Germanicus, better known as Caligula, when tyranny, oppression, lies, schemes, and plots were all tangled together. How can an honest man know what to do?

His concerns show more than just a feeling of general frustration, but they begin to reveal a clear order of reasoning. They are not just vague complaints about unfairness, but they consider a distinction on exactly why he thinks certain things are unjust. In the simplest of terms, the problem isn’t just that people are vicious, but that people are somehow rewarded for being vicious.

My own experience has shown me something quite similar. I can still come to terms with the fact that a man’s thoughts may be selfish, his intentions may be hateful, his words may be dishonest, and his actions may be violent. This is, so to speak, just still within my “comfort zone”, where life provides an obstacle, but the obstacle can still be overcome. It may take some effort, there may be some sacrifices, and it won’t happen overnight, but by the end, the wrong will have been made right. Good wins.

No, the real horror is not only that the wrong never seems to be made right, but also that the wrong just seems to become ever more wrong. All the disordered thoughts, intentions, words, and actions bring the wicked man to even greater success. He not only wants all the wrong things, but he is actually given everything that he wants. His achievement is built on the suffering of the innocent. This is the most unbearable aspect of a world where there is evil.

We can consider the same problem on a higher, and deeper, level, as a question of metaphysics and cosmology, of the order of the Universe itself. This makes it all the more disturbing, and it seems all the more insurmountable.

If we are to posit a God who rules over everything, all-knowing and all-powerful, it doesn’t seem right for him to allow such injustices to occur on his watch. Boethius must confront a question most everyone faces, in one form or another: If God exists, why does he permit the existence of evil? If God does not exist, where is there any hope for a stable good?

These two questions must necessarily go together. God might not exist at all, or at the very least He is too unaware, too weak, or too disinterested to care for such matters, which effectively amounts to much the same thing. Many of us will indeed come to this sort of conclusion, because it is the easiest solution to the fact that our lives are not as fair as we would happen to like them to be.

We may, however, have gone from the fat into the fire. Where can we discover any absolute measure of the good, if God is not its ultimate source? In trying to explain evil by explaining away God, have I not also explained away any possibility of the very just world I would so like to see?

Boethius’ dilemma seems quite formidable, and you and I also struggle with it in our own ways. We might see why God could allow there to be bad men, so that we can learn to fight the good fight. But this seems pointless if there is no chance of winning the fight against them. They always seem to be one step ahead of us.

Written in 6/2015

Caligula: Would you trust this man to be your Emperor, or even sell you a used car?


Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 4.34



Consider, for example, the times of Vespasian. You will see all these things, people marrying, bringing up children, sick, dying, warring, feasting, trafficking, cultivating the ground, flattering, obstinately arrogant, suspecting, plotting, wishing for some to die, grumbling about the present, loving, heaping up treasure, desiring consulship, kingly power. Well then, that life of these people no longer exists at all.

Again, remove to the times of Trajan. Again, all is the same. Their life too is gone. In like manner view also the other epochs of time and of whole nations, and see how many after great efforts soon fell and were resolved into the elements.

But chiefly you should think of those whom you have yourself known distracting themselves about idle things, neglecting to do what was in accordance with their proper constitution, and to hold firmly to this and to be content with it.

And herein it is necessary to remember that the attention given to everything has its proper value and proportion. For thus you will not be dissatisfied, if you apply yourself to smaller matters no further than is fit.

—Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, Book 4 (tr Long)

Few things are as helpful for overcoming our vanities than seeing how passing their true nature is. Time can often give us a new perspective on what we thought was so terribly important, impossible to ignore, or absolutely necessary to address above all else. In the heat of the moment, our priorities can be quite scrambled, because we are acting on the magnitude of how something feels to us then and there, not on what it is in itself.

It is when the force of impressions has faded that things are once again revealed in their proper proportion. Shadows often make things look more frightening than they really are, and clever staging often makes things look more desirable than they really are.

An old saying has it that if I don’t like the weather, I should just wait a minute. Much the same applies to making decisions in the face of certain appearances and circumstances, and the habit of thinking in a bigger context is the key to not confusing greater and lesser goods.

History, of course, is full of such lessons. People spent so much of their energy worried about the most shallow and petty things, none of which offered any peace or contentment then and there, and then they were gone.

I spent much of my childhood surrounded by history, and sometimes I felt a bit overwhelmed by it all, but it always helped me to reflect on distinguishing the things that were temporary or lasting. If my family passed an important monument, grave, or portrait, my mother would often repeat a very Austrian sort of phrase, roughly translated as “Well, his old bones aren’t hurting him anymore!” There was a good bit of sympathy in those words, and then a bit more of a friendly reminder that nothing really stays the same.

One of my own versions has long involved observing how a street or a neighborhood will change, and how what I assumed was an immovable landmark of life might disappear at the moment I look the other way.

An old friend would regularly watch as many of the weekday afternoon soap operas as she possibly could, even if they were just on in the background. This hardly seemed to fit her personality at all, and I had to ask why she found them appealing.

“The stories are ridiculous, the characters are selfish and arrogant, and the stakes are all about useless things,” she said. “I like to be reminded about how not to live, and how much worse my own life could be.”

Well, that actually seems quite sensible. Seeing how people sadly waste their dignity on diversions can soberly remind me to do a better job of ordering my own attention.

Written in 11/2005

Image: Funerary Relief, Syrian (c. 2nd-3rd century AD)

Tuesday, May 1, 2018

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 4.33



Love the art, poor as it may be, that you have learned, and be content with it; and pass through the rest of life like one who has entrusted to the gods with his whole soul all that he has, making yourself neither the tyrant nor the slave of any man.

—Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, Book 4 (tr Long)

I have never had any great skills, and only a very few passing competencies. I had always felt the calling to be teacher, but my eccentric method was never in line with the fashions of the age. I would always, as they say, push the envelope, like some crazed test pilot, in the hopes that this might jar people out of their assumptions. I never wanted people to think like me, but to think for themselves. This novel concept usually does not go over very well.

Though most everyone had given me a list of things I needed to achieve in this life, it was never in me to sell myself out. That left me only one possible goal: Let me do my best to improve myself, regardless of what anyone else may think.

This is, after all, the only kind of art in life that will really make any difference. It can be a lonely art, a neglected art, an art that will not get me any respect from others, but I have learned it is the only one that I need.

What strengths has my aptitude given me? What opportunities has Fortune tossed my way? Whatever they might be, however humble, Providence has provided them for me to use as best I can. It will not matter if I am one of the big men, or one of the small men who clean up the trash left behind by the big men.

Character and integrity don’t admit of status or bragging rights. Put a big fancy hat on the head of a buffoon, and you still have a buffoon, just slightly taller. Put a big fancy hat on the head of a thoughtful man, and he is rightly annoyed that his head now feels too hot.

The way Marcus Aurelius expresses this truth sums it up very nicely for me. I need nothing beyond my own actions, so there is no reason to seek contentment elsewhere. I can accept whatever circumstances may bring, because I trust in the order of Nature. I should give myself completely only to this one task, of serving the true and the right.

I am called to use whatever skill I have to never be the tyrant, to never demand another to be at my pleasure, and to never be the slave, to never be at the pleasure of another. Consider how beautiful a world we would all live in if we chose to take that advice to heart. Living, and letting others live, is only so seemingly impossible when we habitually impose our own preferences upon others, or when we allow other to impose their preferences upon us.

If I choose not to be the bully, will this keep someone else from bullying me? It doesn’t do that at all. Because he loves acquiring power over external things, at the expense of his own soul, the tyrant can often take from me whatever he wants. It is what he doesn’t want, and what he can never take away from me, that will keep me from being a slave. The Universe does not always give us economic or political justice, as much as we may want it to, but it always gives us the chance for moral justice.

Can I build business empires, media conglomerates, or political alliances to push people around and feel important? There may be great art in me, but it is then being used for all the wrong things. This will never make me content. I must offer fully and gladly of whatever I may have, and never demand anything more.

Written in 11/2005