I think of those times in my life when I knew full well how my poor choices had led me to a very dark place, and there was no longer any chance of turning back.
I could try to blame someone else, of course, or rage against the rot in the system, but the responsibility was mine alone, and the worst part was that all of it could have been avoided, if only I had taken a moment to reflect, instead of following my immediate urges.
Tom's vices have cost him his apprenticeship, and he is now forced into a life at sea. While this might seem quite romantic to some, it would not have been easy or pleasant work: his new companions are already tormenting him, as one points to a man hanging from the gallows, while another dangles a frayed rope, to prepare him for the punishment of a cat o' nine tails.
The weeping woman in the boat is surely his mother. She pleads with him, but he turns away with that haughty look so common among young men who are so certain they have it all figured out. The fact that she is also dressed as a widow only goes to show how little he cares about providing for his own.
The copy of his indenture contract has been tossed into the water, though he has likely cast away the best opportunity he could ever receive.
A few "scholarly" accounts of this print seem to assume that Tom has lost his position because Francis has somehow forced him out, and while that is always a possibility, it hardly seems to be compatible with the excellence of character he has already demonstrated.
Perhaps this punishment is the master's last resort, and Tom has simply brought this upon himself. Neither Mr. West nor Francis have shown any signs of being petty and vindictive in the way they do their business, so let us not be so quick to undermine the very foundation of this allegory; not everyone operates from a selfish motive.
For all the times I have been treated poorly by a boss or a colleague, I like to keep in mind those moments, however rare, when someone in power acted with decency and concern. It reminds me why we should not have to settle for laziness or shiftiness, since we can still hope that our betters will have our best interest at heart.
It is unfortunate, however, that an appeal like Hogarth's will most appeal to the fellow who is already forming a conscience, and is unlikely to have much effect on the bounders, the hardened brutes who refuse to be moved by their mother's tears. I now catch myself quietly praying that they will somehow have an epiphany, before it is too late.

No comments:
Post a Comment