Hence, good does not spring from evil, any more than figs grow from olive trees. Things which grow correspond to their seed; and goods cannot depart from their class. As that which is honorable does not grow from that which is base, so neither does good grow from evil. For the honorable and the good are identical.
Certain of our school oppose this statement as follows: “Let us suppose that money taken from any source whatsoever is a good; even though it is taken by an act of sacrilege, the money does not on that account derive its origin from sacrilege.
“You may get my meaning through the following illustration: In the same jar there is a piece of gold and there is a serpent. If you take the gold from the jar, it is not just because the serpent is there too, I say, that the jar yields me the gold—because it contains the serpent as well—but it yields the gold in spite of containing the serpent also.
“Similarly, gain results from sacrilege, not just because sacrilege is a base and accursed act, but because it contains gain also. As the serpent in the jar is an evil, and not the gold which lies there, beside the serpent; so in an act of sacrilege it is the crime, not the profit, that is evil.”
But I differ from these men; for the conditions in each case are not at all the same. In the one instance I can take the gold without the serpent, in the other I cannot make the profit without committing the sacrilege. The gain in the latter case does not lie side by side with the crime; it is blended with the crime.
Certain of our school oppose this statement as follows: “Let us suppose that money taken from any source whatsoever is a good; even though it is taken by an act of sacrilege, the money does not on that account derive its origin from sacrilege.
“You may get my meaning through the following illustration: In the same jar there is a piece of gold and there is a serpent. If you take the gold from the jar, it is not just because the serpent is there too, I say, that the jar yields me the gold—because it contains the serpent as well—but it yields the gold in spite of containing the serpent also.
“Similarly, gain results from sacrilege, not just because sacrilege is a base and accursed act, but because it contains gain also. As the serpent in the jar is an evil, and not the gold which lies there, beside the serpent; so in an act of sacrilege it is the crime, not the profit, that is evil.”
But I differ from these men; for the conditions in each case are not at all the same. In the one instance I can take the gold without the serpent, in the other I cannot make the profit without committing the sacrilege. The gain in the latter case does not lie side by side with the crime; it is blended with the crime.
—from Seneca, Moral Letters 87
The effect will always be a likeness of the cause. Do not permit the sophists to perplex you, because this is a matter of logical identity, and their usual dilemmas are derived from jumbled accounts of the good.
Go back to the beginning, recognizing why our human good is defined by our human nature, through which any other conditions can thereby become beneficial or harmful to us, and then you will no longer be troubled by the contorted conundrums.
I could go on for pages and pages about the gold and the serpent example, along with dozens of others that are intended to trip us up, but I will resist the temptation. It is enough to know how the problems arise from being distracted, by fiddling about with the circumstances alone, instead of relating them back to the proper measure of our understanding.
The critic’s analogy falls short, since the good or the evil is through the disposition, and not, strictly speaking, in either the snake or the money: I do not have to do anything harmful in order to get at something profitable.
Some time ago, I was deeply frustrated by a friend—I use the term loosely—who refused to tell his girlfriend that he was also seeing someone else on the side. I nagged him incessantly to come clean, to be honest about his intentions, on the grounds that nothing would go well for him if he failed to uphold his own integrity.
“What use is the outcome—whether you end up with both of the girls, or one of them, or neither—without the knowledge that you have been a stand-up guy?”
He resisted, of course, and offered many reasons why he could continue to maintain the deception, without any painful consequences. Indeed, he seemed to have convinced himself that he was doing the kindest thing, by not allowing a revelation of the truth to upset anyone’s feelings.
“What she doesn’t know won’t hurt her.”
“Is it your call to decide what she should or shouldn’t know? The best way to help her make the right choice is for you to make the right choice. It will end poorly, not because you will cease to be gratified, but because you will have failed to take any responsibility for yourself.”
He’s a very successful sort of fellow now, though I fear he has yet to learn anything about being a decent sort of fellow. I unfortunately know he is still lying, when he brags about how happy he is.
A few years later, I was on the receiving end of a similar subterfuge, and while I felt great agony from being tricked, there was a far greater sadness from seeing someone I loved turn into a person who was unwilling to love. The good in your life comes from how you choose to give of yourself, not from what you can conspire to receive for yourself.
I cannot isolate the circumstances from one another, based merely upon my preferences, or act as if committing a sin is somehow necessary for getting ahead. It is a conscience, whether informed or deficient, that will bind it all together or tear it all apart.
The effect will always be a likeness of the cause. Do not permit the sophists to perplex you, because this is a matter of logical identity, and their usual dilemmas are derived from jumbled accounts of the good.
Go back to the beginning, recognizing why our human good is defined by our human nature, through which any other conditions can thereby become beneficial or harmful to us, and then you will no longer be troubled by the contorted conundrums.
I could go on for pages and pages about the gold and the serpent example, along with dozens of others that are intended to trip us up, but I will resist the temptation. It is enough to know how the problems arise from being distracted, by fiddling about with the circumstances alone, instead of relating them back to the proper measure of our understanding.
The critic’s analogy falls short, since the good or the evil is through the disposition, and not, strictly speaking, in either the snake or the money: I do not have to do anything harmful in order to get at something profitable.
Some time ago, I was deeply frustrated by a friend—I use the term loosely—who refused to tell his girlfriend that he was also seeing someone else on the side. I nagged him incessantly to come clean, to be honest about his intentions, on the grounds that nothing would go well for him if he failed to uphold his own integrity.
“What use is the outcome—whether you end up with both of the girls, or one of them, or neither—without the knowledge that you have been a stand-up guy?”
He resisted, of course, and offered many reasons why he could continue to maintain the deception, without any painful consequences. Indeed, he seemed to have convinced himself that he was doing the kindest thing, by not allowing a revelation of the truth to upset anyone’s feelings.
“What she doesn’t know won’t hurt her.”
“Is it your call to decide what she should or shouldn’t know? The best way to help her make the right choice is for you to make the right choice. It will end poorly, not because you will cease to be gratified, but because you will have failed to take any responsibility for yourself.”
He’s a very successful sort of fellow now, though I fear he has yet to learn anything about being a decent sort of fellow. I unfortunately know he is still lying, when he brags about how happy he is.
A few years later, I was on the receiving end of a similar subterfuge, and while I felt great agony from being tricked, there was a far greater sadness from seeing someone I loved turn into a person who was unwilling to love. The good in your life comes from how you choose to give of yourself, not from what you can conspire to receive for yourself.
I cannot isolate the circumstances from one another, based merely upon my preferences, or act as if committing a sin is somehow necessary for getting ahead. It is a conscience, whether informed or deficient, that will bind it all together or tear it all apart.
—Reflection written in 2/2014
IMAGE: Vincent van Gogh, Olive Trees in a Mountainous Landscape (1889)

No comments:
Post a Comment