Reflections

Primary Sources

Tuesday, May 14, 2019

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 10.13.1

Inquire of yourself, as soon as you wake from sleep, whether it will make any difference to you if another does what is just and right.

It will make no difference.

—Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, Book 10.13 (tr Long)

It is hardly that the thoughts, words, or actions of others are unimportant or meaningless; they certainly form the character of others, and they certainly play their particular role in the order of all things working together.

The question, however, is how I will choose to have them affect me in the forming of my own character. They will only matter as much to me as I allow them to matter, and whatever good or bad may come of them will depend ultimately on my own estimation.

This seems quite ridiculous if my mindset is built upon the assumption that I am defined by my circumstances, and therefore that the good or bad that others do will determine what is good or bad for me.

But a Stoic mindset turns the tables. Starting with the premise that what completes a rational nature is grounded in its own judgments and choices, I will then see that the benefit or harm of any conditions will flow from what I decide to do with the conditions.

Has another acted with compassion and concern? This is an opportunity for me to practice these same virtues. Has another acted with malice and contempt? This also is an opportunity, now for me to practice the virtues that oppose his vices. Participate with what is right, or stand up against what is wrong. The paths may be different, but my ultimate destination can remain the same, the practice of good living.

The waking moment is perhaps the best time to reflect upon this, before I become caught up in all the hustle and bustle, and when I can still calmly make decisions for the coming day.

If I look back at my earlier mistakes, I will see that I am prone to responding to the wrongdoings of others in one of two ways. Sometimes I sulk, treating myself as a victim, and I feel sorry for myself. At other times I lash out, condemning my perceived enemies, and I react with force and resentment. Neither of these is necessary, and neither of them will do me, or others, any good at all.

When I remember that my own life is not measured by what may or may not happen, but rather that it is my own life that gives events their very measure, then I will not have to face the coming day with fear or anxiety. It will be as it will be, and I already have everything I need inside of me to make sense and find purpose within what will be.

What another man does will not make any difference. How I react to what another man does will make all the difference. 

Written in 1/2009 

No comments:

Post a Comment