Reflections

Primary Sources

Thursday, October 25, 2018

Boethius, The Consolation 2.24


“We have heard what ruin Nero wrought
 when Rome was burnt and senators were slain.
We know how savagely he did to death his brother,
how he was stained by the spilling of his own mother's blood,
and how he looked upon her cold body
and yet no tear fell upon his cheek;
yet this man was judge of the morals of those who were dead.
Nay, he was ruler of the peoples whom the sun looks upon
from the time he rises in the east
until he hides his rays beneath the waves,
and those whom the chilling northern stars overrule,
and those whom the southern gale burns with its dry blast,
as it heats the burning sands.
Say, could great power chasten Nero's maddened rage?
Ah! heavy fate, how often is the sword of high injustice
given where is already most poisonous cruelty!”

—from Book 2, Poem 6

We are so easily impressed by wealth, fame, and power, even as they are never what will make us good. Like any nation, Rome had its great leaders, and its terrible leaders. All the emperors had power, but the great ones were defined by their virtue, and the terrible ones by their vice. You may give a man dominion over everything outside of him, but it is the qualities of the heart and mind within him that will determine how he exercises that dominion.

Perhaps Nature permits brutal tyrants to come our way to remind us where true value lies, and that power is never an assurance of excellence. Every generation will have its fair share of despots and oppressors, sometimes so many of them that we have a hard time finding anyone who will rule with benevolence.

Though it can sometimes be difficult to unravel the facts from the legends, the name of Nero stands out as one of those warnings of what happens when you mix great power with a crooked soul. Few things can be more horrifying than overwhelming strength combined with depraved cruelty. We can see it in ancient Rome, just as we can see it around us today, constant proof that authority and influence do not make a good man.

The autocrats and bullies come in many shapes and sizes, and the small ones can sometimes be just as frightening as the big ones. I once had the misfortune of working with an administrator who took a sinister delight in inflicting suffering on those he disliked. He seemed to take special pleasure in making women cry. He had the ear of a superior, and was a master of manipulation, so his position was virtually unassailable. I did my best to avoid him at all costs, because he made my skin crawl. The most frightening thing about him was the way he would flash a sinister little grin and rub his hands together whenever he got his way. We have surely all known the sorts of people who make us want to run for the hills.

I’m not sure that power makes men evil, because I have known those who will rule with justice and kindness, but I do suspect that power makes bad men even worse. It gives them the tools they crave to impose their wills, and becomes an opportunity for them to acquire the sense of importance they think they deserve. For some, the craving for greater and greater influence becomes like a sort of addiction to feed their vanity.

And yet we still so often admire power, we still think it somehow worthy, and we still wish to possess it for ourselves, forgetting that it is in itself of no real merit at all. It is the character of the man who wields it that will make it good or evil, and so I am well advised to pay far greater attention to building virtue than acquiring power. 

Written in 9/2015

IMAGE: Alphonse Mucha, Nero Watching the Fire of Rome (1887) 

No comments:

Post a Comment